The Origins of the Christian Mystical Tradition by Andrew Louth (review)

The Origins of the Christian Mystical Tradition: From Plato to DenysThe Origins of the Christian Mystical Tradition: From Plato to Denys by Andrew Louth
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This book is a fine piece of introduction and analysis of what may, rather then ‘mystical’, more precisely be considered the contemplative strand of Christianity as it took on and then adapted (or at times rejected) the Platonic inheritance. The 2006 edition is definitely to be preferred, for in this edition Louth closes with a very challenging Afterword wherein he confronts the very concept of mysticism. We all think we know what the word means, but probably we don’t.

After chapters on Plato, Philo, and Plotinus, Louth discusses Origen; ‘Nicene Orthodoxy’ which includes Athanasius (who raises an anti-‘mystical’ challenge to Platonism) and Gregory of Nyssa; ‘The Monastic Contribution’ which considers Evagrius of Pontus (the rich but problematic Origenist/Platonist), the Macarian Homilies, and Diadochus of Photiki who brings out strands in both of the other two in this chapter; Augustine of Hippo’s contribution; then Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite (whom he refers to as ‘Denys’).

Living in a post-Carmelite age whose understanding of Christian ‘mysticism’ is indelibly marked by the late medieval and early modern inheritance, Chapter 9 is an important discussion of St John of the Cross and the patristic inheritance. Louth argues that there is, indeed, some difference, but more often of style and perspective than content. The final chapter is ‘The Mystical Life and the Mystical Body’. This final chapter reminds us of a chief difference between ancient Christian ‘mysticism’ and the philosophers, for the ancient Christians always thought in terms of the Christian community, the liturgy, and the communion of saints, rather than Plotinus flight of the alone to the Alone.

In each of the ancient philosophers or patristic authors analysed, Louth gives us a run-through of what we may consider his ‘mystical’ teaching, looking both at their reception and at their challenge of Platonist ideas. It is a helpful book in many ways, although one is reminded that most of the praktike of the contemplative tradition in Christianity is the pursuit of moral virtue and askesis rather than the delineation of particular psychological practices as taught by the baptised Buddhism of Anthony de Mello, S.J., in Sadhana. I would have liked to have seen more on Diadochus and the Jesus Prayer, since the Jesus Prayer is the heart of so much of what we may consider Eastern Orthodox ‘mysticism’ today.

In the end, I recommend this book. At times it is challenging to read. At times, since it is introductory, it feels not quite deep enough. But overall, it gives you some idea of the landscape of these authors and this strand, as well as questions to take with you on your own journey into the broad literature of Christian spirituality.

View all my reviews

8 thoughts on “The Origins of the Christian Mystical Tradition by Andrew Louth (review)

  1. I found this book helpful just in bringing together a lot of points I had acquired in more scattered fashion. I’d read a fair amount on the Greek view of the Trinity, for instance, but Louth’s chapter really clarified for me how that tradition sees itself as different from the Latin/Western.

    • Yes, it is very good at exactly that — bringing together points a lot of us will have picked up in disparate places and then putting them in some sort of coherent narrative.

  2. Very much enjoying learning about Christian mysticism through your blog. I’m very much interested in mystical traditions across the world’s religions (it’s one of the focuses of my blog), so I’m looking forward to reading yours more in depth. Do you have any recommendations for a definitive introduction to Christian mysticism?

    • Glad you enjoy the mysticism posts! I think it depends on one’s approach and how much time one has. I’d recommend Bernard McGinn, The Presence of God in three volumes for definitive, but each volume is pretty long. That said, you’ll get more from that than many other places! Outdated but still of interest is Evelyn Underhill, Mysticism.

      As an introduction to current western Christian mysticism, Thomas Merton, The Inner Experience, which is a final revision after many decades of one of his earlier works, still being revised during his lfietime, is good. For Eastern Christianity, Vladimir Lossky, The Mystical Theology of the Eastern Church is what many recommend; just be cautious of what he says about western Christianity!

      Another approach is starting in with anthologies and then spreading out to the full texts they excerpt. McGinn has The Essential Writings of Christian Mysticism and Dupre and Wiseman have Light from Light.

      • Thank you so much! I’ll definitely check these out. I’ve already got a copy of Evelyn Underhill’s book on my computer, and these others look pretty great

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.